EU battles in court to overturn Apple tax bill ruling / Photo: Lionel BONAVENTURE - AFP/File
-
'Project Hail Mary' tops N. America box office for second week
-
Forty new migratory species win international protection: UN body
-
Freed whale gets stranded again on German coast
-
Ter Stegen's World Cup chances 'very slim', says Nagelsmann
-
Pakistan hosts Saudi, Turkey, Egypt for talks on Mideast war
-
Tudor leaves after just seven games as Spurs battle for survival
-
Philipsen sprints to In Flanders Fields victory
-
In Israel, air raid sirens spark anxiety and dilemmas
-
Iran accuses US of plotting ground attack despite diplomatic talk
-
Vingegaard clinches Tour of Catalonia victory
-
Despondent Verstappen questions Formula One future
-
Two more arrests over attempted attack on US bank HQ in Paris
-
Nepal's ex-PM attends court hearing in protest crackdown case
-
Iran parliament speaker says US planning ground attack
-
Despondent Verstappen says Red Bull woes 'not sustainable'
-
Piastri says Japan second place 'as good as a win' for McLaren
-
Nepal's former energy minister arrested in graft probe
-
IOC reinstating gender tests 'a disrespect for women' - Semenya
-
Youngest F1 title leader Antonelli to keep 'raising bar' after Japan win
-
High hopes at China's gateway to North Korea as trains resume
-
Antonelli wins in Japan to become youngest F1 championship leader
-
Mercedes' Antonelli wins Japanese Grand Prix to take lead
-
Germany's WWII munitions a toxic legacy on Baltic Sea floor
-
Iran claims aluminium plant attacks in Gulf as Houthis join war
-
North Korea's Kim oversees test of high-thrust engine: state media
-
Five Apple anecdotes as iPhone maker marks 50 years
-
'Excited' Buttler rejuvenated for IPL after horror T20 World Cup
-
Ship insurers juggle war risks for perilous Gulf route
-
Helplines buzz with alerts from seafarers trapped in war
-
Let's get physical: Singapore's seniors turn to parkour
-
Indian tile makers feel heat of Mideast war energy crunch
-
At 50, Apple confronts its next big challenge: AI
-
Houthis missile attacks on Israel widen Middle East war
-
Massive protests against Trump across US on 'No Kings' day
-
Struggling Force lament missed opportunities after Chiefs defeat
-
Lakers guard Doncic gets one-game ban for accumulated technicals
-
Houthis claim missile attacks on Israel, entering Middle East war
-
NBA Spurs stretch win streak to eight in rout of Bucks
-
US lose 5-2 to Belgium in rude awakening for World Cup hosts
-
Sabalenka sinks Gauff to win second straight Miami Open title
-
Lebanon kids struggle to keep up studies as war slams school doors shut
-
Cherry blossoms, kite-flying and 'No Kings' converge on Washington
-
Britain's Kerr to target El Guerrouj's mile world record
-
Sailboats carrying aid reach Cuba after going missing: AFP journalist
-
Pakistan to host Saudi, Turkey, Egypt for talks on Mideast war
-
Formidable Sinner faces Lehecka for second Miami Open title
-
Tuchel plays down Maguire's World Cup hopes
-
'Risky moment': Ukraine treads tightrope with Gulf arms deals
-
Japan strike late to win Scotland friendly
-
India great Ashwin joining San Francisco T20 franchise
EU battles in court to overturn Apple tax bill ruling
Apple and Brussels butted heads in a top EU court on Tuesday as the bloc battled to overturn a ruling against its whopping 13-billion euro order on the iPhone-maker to pay Ireland in back taxes.
The landmark case remains one of the most bitter between the European Commission and a big tech firm, dating back to 2016 when the EU's executive arm accused Ireland of allowing Apple to escape 13 billion euros ($14 billion) in taxes between 2003 and 2014.
The EU alleged that Apple parked untaxed revenue earned in Europe, Africa, the Middle East and India in Ireland, which is a European hub for US-based big tech.
Brussels claims this amounted to illegal "state aid" by Ireland.
On Tuesday, the bloc's highest court heard the commission's appeal against a 2020 decision by the EU's lower General Court to annul its order that Apple repay the money.
The commission's lawyer, Paul-John Loewenthal, told the European Court of Justice (ECJ) that there had been a "breach of procedure" and "numerous other legal errors" when the lower court heard the case.
He also said the "tax breaks" resulted in Apple's Irish subsidiary "paying an effective tax rate on its European profits starting at one percent in 2003 down to 0.005 percent in 2014".
"Tax breaks which Apple itself described (to the US Senate) as investment incentives amounting to state aid," Loewenthal said.
Apple's lawyer Daniel Beard pushed back against Loewenthal's claims.
"Apple has paid the taxes that were due under the Irish tax code," Beard said.
"Taking quotes to the US Senate completely out of context doesn't change that."
The lawyer dismissed Brussels' accusations of illegal support from Ireland, insisting "there was no special treatment, there was no state aid".
Apple has been present in Ireland since the 1980s and employs more than 6,000 people in Cork, the country's second-largest city.
The ECJ's top legal advisor will issue an opinion on November 9, with a final ruling expected a few months later by judges that are not bound by the advice.
The EU has faced difficulty justifying its tax decisions in recent years with previous court losses against Amazon and Starbucks.
P.Serra--PC
